A Feature Article from Gaynor Consulting Inc.
talking leadership
Difficult Conversations

February 2012

Has this article sparked some thinking? Join our blog Talking Leadership here to share it with other readers.

By Dan Gaynor

“The real art of conversation is not only to say the right thing in the right place but to leave unsaid the wrong thing at the tempting moment.” Dorothy Nevill. English Writer (1826-1913)

THE BEST LEADERS SURFACE AND RESOLVE THE MOST IMPORTANT QUESTIONS ABOUT people and their work: questions surrounding someone’s willingness to change a problematic behavior or those that arise when the time to move on has arrived. Difficult conversations can also turn around faltering performance and restore success. They are vital to the health of the team and the individual. Every successful leader’s career is filled with opportunities for them. When you get right down to it, great teams are built one conversation at a time. The best leaders step forward into these conversations confidently and skillfully, less effective leaders avoid them.

The art of conversation is among every leader’s most valuable assets. Accepting the reality that this takes time to develop, here are five principles to help you along the way:

Don’t avoid
Like any other skill, this one only comes with practice. Avoiding a difficult conversation is not doing or saying the right thing so decide to engage. Good leadership is filled with them.

Stay constructive
Dorothy Nevill’s opening quote directs us to the next principle - stay constructive. These are often the most emotionally charged conversations, so determine to say only that which will improve the situation for everyone involved - once again, don’t avoid what should be said, say it constructively. Resist the temptation to say the wrong thing when you are provoked, these moments will arise. You are in the power position and this brings with it the responsibility for self-control.

Prepare well
Because these conversations are often so emotional, they can get off track if you are not well organized. The pressure you feel makes it more difficult so stay on course, particularly when you are new to these encounters, so prepare in advance by making notes. If you’re nervous take the notes with you. Tell the individual that it is an important conversation and so you are going to work from notes.

Be respectful
The moment someone feels you are being disrespectful the focus of the conversation changes: the disrespect becomes the issue. When someone gets defensive, stop the conversation and deal with this. I will often say something like, “I want you to know we’re having this conversation because I want to help you, so I want you to accept it in spirit in which it’s being offered.” If this doesn’t succeed, I’ll discuss the reality that it’s my job to provide corrective feedback when its warranted and that I need employees who can accept it - people who demonstrate they can be coached. When the right tone has been re-established move back to the topic.

Be encouraging
All good leaders are natural encouragers. When someone is discouraged, and this can happen at any point in these conversations, good leaders encourage. Ending on a note of encouragement with a statement like, “I know this was tough to hear, but I also know you can change it if you want to” provided this is truthful, can make all the difference and motivate someone to really work at the feedback you’ve provided. No matter the topic, there is always a way to encourage.

These conversation are essential, the ability to hold them with skill and grace is the mark of great leaders. Make it a priority to polish this art until it shines.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS:

1. Is there a difficult conversation that you have been avoiding?
2. Can you recall being on the receiving end of a difficult but important conversation, was it held skillfully?
3. Which of the five principles will help you improve the most?

To go deeper on key leadership skills why not contact us for more on a half day workshop.

 
 
Bookmark and Share

5 Fundamentals: Taking Stock, Jan. 2012

You Are Not What You Do, Dec. 2011

Talking Performance and Job Fit, Nov. 2011

Loyalty In Leadership, Oct. 2011

Under Fire, Sept. 2011

Four Keys to Leadership Development, Aug. 2011

Power as Control, July 2011

Leader as Teacher, June 2011

Power in Relationships, May, 2011

The Power of a Goal, Apr. 2011

Work As A Creative Zone, Mar. 2011

Uncooperative Cast Members, Feb. 2011

Inspiring With Vision, Jan. 2011

Misfits, Dec. 2010

The Dandelion Effect, Nov. 2010

Purposeful About Culture, Oct. 2010

The Case for Self-Restraint, Sept. 2010

Leadership, Not for Everyone, Aug. 2010

From Supervisor to CEO, July 2010

Aversion to Conflict, June 2010

The Choice Between Resiliency & Surrender, May 2010

Revisiting Servant Leadership, Apr. 2010

Feedback as the DNA of Team Development, Mar. 2010

Positional and Relationship Power, Feb. 2010

Building a Coaching Relationship, Jan. 2010

The Power of Sacrifice, Dec. 2009

Communication that Connects, Nov. 2009

Accountability & the Corporate Body, Oct. 2009

The Four Outcomes to Feedback, Sept. 2009

Urgency is a Powerful Force, Aug. 2009

Achievement Drives Performance, July 2009

Pressure, The Truest Test of the Heart, June 2009

Insist on Best Effort, May 2009

The Power of Encouragement, Apr. 2009

Values Underpin Performance, Mar. 2009

Lessons from the Inauguration, Feb. 2009

Share Your Plans, Jan. 2009

Hiring the Right People, Dec. 2008

Leading Through Turmoil, Nov. 2008

Five Qualities of Good Direction, Oct, 2008

Grace Under Pressure, Sept. 2008

Feedback in a Fishbowl, Aug. 2008

The Power of Humility, July 2008

Make Every Performance Count, June 2008

Favouritism & Fairness, May 2008

Making Vision Matter (Part Two), Apr. 2008

Making Vision Matter (Part One), Mar. 2008

Make Opinions Matter, Feb. 2008

The Newcomer Challenge, Jan. 2008

Ebenezer and Leadership, Dec. 2007

The Heart of Accountability, Nov. 2007

Get the Focus Right, Oct. 2007

The Buy-in Problem, Sept. 2007

Teambuilding for Performance, Aug. 2007

Work Less, Do More, July 2007

You Must Follow Well to Lead Well, June 2007

Inspire Others With Possibilities, May 2007

The Doctrine of Distance, Apr. 2007

We Do Not Work Alone, We Are In This Together, Mar. 2007

 
Gaynor Consulting Inc.